In 1935, the Essex County commissioners proposed a vote on whether to serve turkey to the prisoners of the Salem jail on Thanksgiving, according to a news report in the Boston Traveler:
“A couple of tough questions were put up to the Essex county commissioners meeting here today…Should they serve turkey instead of pork in Salem jail on Thanksgiving day and invite trouble among prisoners fighting for drumsticks?”
The reason for the vote was because, as the article suggests, the jail had stopped serving turkey on Thanksgiving years ago because the prisoners fought over the drumsticks and prison officials feared it would lead to further violence.

It’s not clear when exactly the jail stopped serving turkey, but according to various news reports, other institutions in Salem , such as the Salem almshouse, the Bertram Home for Aged Men, the Old Ladies Home, and the City Orphan Asylum, were still serving turkey on Thanksgiving while the jail was serving roast pork and mince pie as far back as 1906 (“Thanksgiving Day in Salem,” 1906).

Pork was used as a substitute because it didn’t have anything the prisoners could fight over and was also cheaper than turkey. A problem arose in the mid-1930s, though, when pork suddenly became expensive and prison officials wondered if it would be safe to go back to serving turkey again, according to the news report:
“A few years ago turkey was a jail Thanksgiving fixture. But the prisoners began to fight over drumsticks. The commissioner did away with drumsticks–they ordered pork. Now pork is a luxury. Turkey can be bought for less. To economize and to allow drumsticks–that is the question.”
It appears from a news report just two years earlier that the jail had actually tried to serve turkey on Christmas Day in 1931 but ran into the usual problems of prisoners fighting over the drumsticks and had decided to go back to serving pork again:
“’We’re going to serve pork this year,’ announced Sheriff Frank E. Raymond today. ‘We’ve tried turkey on the menu, only to find that the prisoners all want white meat, or a leg, or a wing. Little disputes arose over the distribution of the various sections of the birds. When you have pork, you know, it’ll be pork no matter how you carve it.’” (“Plebian Pork Replaces Traditional Turkey,” 1932)
According to a quote from Sheriff Raymond in a news report in the Pawtucket Times, the disputes were primarily over the turkey legs:
“’Turkeys don’t have enough legs for this jail,’ he sighed. ‘It will be roast pork this year.’ The sigh was in memory over the Yule dinner in 1931 when his guests created some unpleasantness because the turkey legs could not be given to all.”
It’s not known if the jail ever went back to serving turkey again at either Thanksgiving or Christmas. The jail eventually closed in 1991, when a newer jail was built in nearby Middleton, and the old jail has since been converted into an apartment building.
Sources:
“Thanksgiving Day in Salem.” The Salem Gazette, 30 Nov. 1906, p. 1.
“Plebian Pork Replaces Traditional Turkey at Salem Jail This Xmas.” Amesbury Daily News, 15 Dec. 1932, p. 1.
“Turkey is Barred in Salem Jail Christmas.” Pawtucket Times, 15 Dec. 1932, p. 11.
“Battle of Drumsticks Threatens Salem Jail as Thanksgiving Looms.” The Boston Traveler, 21 Nov. 1935, p. 2.
