History of the Pickering House in Salem, Massachusetts

Built sometime around 1660, the Pickering House is the oldest house in Salem, Massachusetts, to be continuously occupied by one family.

The house was built by John Pickering Jr., a local farmer and town official, and was occupied by 10 generations of the Pickering family.

Although it has been renovated over the years, the house was originally a two-room farmhouse that consisted only of the present south-east rooms and the chimney bay.

The section of land the house was built on was originally owned by Thomas Antrum, who conveyed it to his brother-in-law Edmond Batter. Batter then transferred it to brothers John Pickering Jr. and Jonathan Pickering on June 10, 1659.

Pickering House, Salem, Mass circa 1910
Pickering House, Salem, Mass circa 1910

It is believed Jonathan gave the lot to his brother John soon after, and the house was built on the lot the following year, according to Salem historian Sidney Perley in an article in the Essex Antiquarian magazine in 1900.

John Pickering Jr. was a lieutenant in the local militia and was living in the house at the time he fought in the Battle of Bloody Brook in Deerfield during King Philip’s War in 1675.

In 1682, Pickering Jr. expanded the house by adding another room and chamber to the left of the chimney.

In 1694, Pickering Jr. died and the house passed down to his son, John Pickering. When John died in 1722, the house passed down to his son Deacon Timothy Pickering.

Dining Room, Pickering House, photo published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914
Dining Room, Pickering House, photo published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914

In 1751, Deacon Pickering expanded the house by adding a second story to the lean-to.

On July 17, 1745, Colonel Timothy Pickering was born in the house. Timothy later grew up to become a judge in the Massachusetts General Court, a colonel and then adjutant general in the Revolutionary War, and the Secretary of State for the United States government in 1795. He became such a prominent citizen of Salem that Fort Pickering on Winter Island in Salem was named after him in 1799.

Colonel Pickering was living in the house when he helped fend off British soldiers in Salem during Leslie’s Retreat in February of 1775 and also when he fought at the Battle of Lexington in 1775.

Pickering was later appointed Quartermaster General of the Continental Army by George Washington and was present at the battles of Brandywine and Germantown and Cornwallis’ surrender.

Alcove, Pickering House, Salem, photo published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914
Alcove, Pickering House, Salem, photo published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914

When Deacon Pickering died in 1778, he was buried in the Broad Street Cemetery across the street, and the house passed down to Colonel Timothy Pickering.

It is rumored that George Washington stopped by the house and tied his horse to an old locust tree in the front yard when he visited Colonel Pickering in 1789 (New Boston 56.)

After Colonel Pickering died in 1829, the house passed down to his son, John Pickering, Esquire.

Hallway, Pickering House, photo  published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914
Hallway, Pickering House, photo published in Historic Homes of New England in 1914

In 1841, the exterior of the house was renovated in the Gothic Revival style with window hoods, new facade gables, and a balustrade above the front entrance, and a fence.

When John Pickering Esquire died in 1846, the house passed down to his son, also named John Pickering. John Pickering died in 1882 and then passed it down to his son, also named John Pickering. In 1904, a new wing was added to the rear of the house.

In 1906, the house was in danger of demolition when Salem Mayor Thomas G. Pinnock proposed razing the historic house to build a new high school. Pinnock even said he was in favor of seizing the property under eminent domain if the Pickering family refused to sell.

News report about the proposal to tear down the Pickering House to build a new high school. Published in the Boston Herald on January 13, 1906.

The plan never came to fruition because it didn’t have support from other officials. Alden P. White, president of the board of aldermen, told the Boston Herald that he opposed the plan for a number of reasons:

“’I am not in favor of the plan,’ he said to a Herald man last night. ‘I think it is a shame to touch a place like that. More than that, it is a poor business policy. Places of that sort are assets to the city. They bring people to the city who come here to see places of that sort. I shall be seriously opposed to disturbing it.”

Former Mayor John Hurley reiterated this point to the Herald, stating how famous Salem is for its historic buildings:

“’It’s a shame,’ said Mr. Hurley. ‘Not a single one of those places should be touched. They are what makes Salem famous. People may not realize how many people come here to see those places. I sell souvenir postal cards and you can form a fair estimate of the people who come to Salem to see the Pickering house when I tell you that I find it impossible to keep pictures of the old house in stock. They are purchased faster than they can be made.’”

Other opponents to the plan included William H. McSweeney, president of the common council; Sidney Perley, a Salem lawyer and local historian; and school board member Joseph E. Saunders, who insisted the school board would vote against any such proposal.

News report about the proposal to tear down the Pickering House to build a new high school. Published in the Salem Gazette on February 28, 1906.

In 1948, the interior of the house was restored by Boston architect Gordon Robb. The following year, the house officially opened to the public as a historic house museum.

The last members of the Pickering family moved out in 1998 when the Goodhue family moved into the house and Albert Goodhue began serving as the primary caretaker.

In 2001, the Pickering Foundation was formed, which is currently led by John Pickering. The house is owned by the Pickering Foundation and still operates as a historic house museum.

In 2010, the Pickering Foundation published a history book about the Pickering family and the house titled The House That John Built: Ten Generations of the Pickering Family of Salem.

Sources:
“Old Pickering Homestead in Danger.” The Boston Herald, 13 Jan. 1906, p. 4.
“Old Historic Site.” Salem Gazette, 28 Feb. 1906, p. 1.
“Old Pickering House for High School?” The Boston Record, 11 Jan. 1906, p. 5.
“Antique Relic From House in Which Col. Pickering Was Born.” Daily Evening Item, 22 Jun. 1907, p. 9.
“Pickering House Opened for Summer to Salem Visitors.” The Boston Globe, 3 Jun. 1949, p. 9.
Perley, Sidney. “Part of Salem in 1700 No 5.” The Essex Antiquarian, Volume IV, No. 11, Essex Institute, November 1900
New Boston: Chronicle of Progress in Developing a Greater and Finer City – Under the Auspices of the Boston 1915 Movement. Editor: James Phinney Monroe, Vol II, No 2, 1911
Northend, Mary Harrod. Historic Homes of New England. Little, Brown and Company, 1914
“Appendix I.” Colonial Society of Massachusetts, colonialsociety.org/node/1967
“Pickering Foundation in Salem, Mass.” Buzzfile, buzzfile.com/business/Pickering-Foundation-978-744-4777
“The Pickering House.” Oxford-Tree Ring Laboratory, dendrochronology.com/pck.html
“Pikering House.” MACRIS, Massachusetts Cultural Resource Information System, mhc-macris.net/Details.aspx?MhcId=SAL.1044

About Rebecca Beatrice Brooks

Rebecca Beatrice Brooks is the author and publisher of the History of Massachusetts Blog. Rebecca is a journalist and history writer who got her start in journalism working for small-town newspapers in Massachusetts and New Hampshire after she graduated from the University of New Hampshire with a B.A. in journalism. She is a member of Historic Salem Inc, the Danvers Historical Society, and the Salisbury Historical Society and she volunteers for the National Archives and the Massachusetts Historical Society transcribing historical documents. Visit this site's About page to find out more about Rebecca.

3 thoughts on “History of the Pickering House in Salem, Massachusetts”

  1. Anna

    Thank you for compiling such a wonderfully concise history! I just have a quick a correction! Col. Tim Pickering never owned the house. Col. Tim’s father, Deacon Tim, left the house to his eldest son John Pickering (5th generation). When John5 died childless, the house was then passed to John6, Col. Tim’s son.

    Thank you again!

Leave a Reply