Although Booth was a national star, he was especially popular in Boston, a city he loved for its charm and culture, and had performed in numerous plays at the local playhouse, the Boston Museum.
Booth sent a letter to his friend Joseph Simmonds, a teller at Boston’s Mechanics Bank, who was helping him with his land purchase, on April 3rd of that year inquiring about the lots for sale along Commonwealth Avenue:
“Dear Joe, Did you or Orlando send me that catalog of Back Bay lands to be sold April 9th. However, find out about them. For lots No. 5,6,7 or 9 (any one of them) on the north side of Commonwealth Avenue. I will bid as high as $2.70 per foot (their minimum value is $2.25). If you fail to get any one of the above, I will bid on corner lot (Commonwealth Avenue) No. 20. as high as $3.25 per foot. If you are not out bid and fail to get any of them, I will bid on any one (single lot) on south side of Marlborough Street as high as 20 percent above its minimum valuation (a corner lot preferred.) Attend to this, dear Joe. See Keach who said something about the auctioneer being sorry he did not know I wanted to buy last time. Let Orlando see this. Advise with him about it. He promised to buy from me, or to let me know about it. I don’t care about the lots on Marlborough St. If I buy one of them, it will be on spec. So if you miss Commonwealth Ave, strike light on the first….Yours truly, J. Wilkes Booth”
Booth purchased a lot, located at 115 Commonwealth Avenue, for $8,192 and placed it under his mother’s name, Mary Ann Booth. Around the same time he also bought $1,500 worth of Boston Water Co. shares.
The house Booth planned to build never came to fruition, probably due to a bad oil investment he made in Pennsylvania in 1864 that seriously depleted his fortune.
Since Booth never built his house in Boston, he stayed at the Omni Parker House hotel the last time he visited the city, on April 5 and 6 of 1865, just ten days before he killed Abraham Lincoln, and was seen practicing shooting his pistol at a nearby shooting gallery on the corner of Chapman and School streets.
It is not clear if Mary Ann Booth sold the Commonwealth avenue lot after Booth’s death, but in 1876 a large home was built on the lot for dry good merchant Walter Hastings Jr. The building was eventually subdivided into apartments after the 1970s.
The building is currently up for sale, with an asking price of $11,500,000, according to the Classic Realty web site.
In a strange coincidence, Booth’s nemesis, Abraham Lincoln, also had connections to Massachusetts when it was later discovered that he descended from colonists who settled in Massachusetts in the 17th century. Even stranger, the man who later killed Booth, Boston Corbett, also had connections to Boston after he moved there in the 1850s, had a religious conversion there and changed his name from Thomas to Boston in honor of the city.
Classic Realty; 115 Commonwealth Avenue Boston: http://www.classic-realty.com/115-commonwealth-avenue-boston/
BOSArchitecture: Back Bay: http://www.bosarchitecture.com/backbay/commonwealth/115.html
Lust for Fame: The Stage Career of John Wilkes Booth; Gordon Samples; 1998
Boston Sights and Insights; Susan Wilson; 2004
The Boston Globe Guide to Boston; Jerry Morris; 2005
American Brutus: John Wilkes Booth and the Lincoln Conspiracies; Michael W. Kauffman; 2005
Right or Wrong, God Judge Me: The Writings of John Wilkes Booth; John Wilkes Booth; 1997